Cash Discount vs Surcharge Calculator for Manufacturers
Manufacturers often take large, invoiced card payments from customers who could just as easily pay by ACH or check. Use your own statement numbers to see what each program could recover on those payments, and how much more a buyer's purchasing team would see on a typical invoice.
Your comparison
Estimates are based on published industry averages and are not a quote. Actual rates depend on card mix, ticket size, industry, and underwriting.
What your customers would pay
| Posted price today | Cash discount: cash price | Cash discount: card price | Surcharge: credit price | Surcharge: debit or cash price |
|---|
Monthly breakdown
| Per month | Cash discount | Surcharge |
|---|
Who sees a higher price
Signage and disclosure checklist to confirm
These items are commonly required. Each one is something to confirm with the card brands, your processor, and your state; none of it is a legal determination.
Questions to ask any processor before signing up
Estimates are based on published industry averages and are not a quote. Actual rates depend on card mix, ticket size, industry, and underwriting.
A specialist can review your statement and walk through how either program would be set up on your POS. This is not a quote. Rules vary by state, so confirm with the card brands and your state before launching.
How manufacturers should fill in each input
Choose B2B as your business type. If you leave current fees blank, the tool uses an industry estimate of 2.8% for B2B. That is an assumption, not your rate. Commercial and purchasing cards and key-entered invoice payments can push your real cost higher or lower, so enter the total fees from a recent statement whenever you can. Include every line item, not just the discount rate.
For share of customers who pay cash, count the customers who pay the posted price today, which for most manufacturers means ACH, check, or wire. Whether a given cash discount program treats ACH the same as cash depends on the program terms, so confirm before you rely on that number.
Do not accept the 35% debit default without checking. Many manufacturers process mostly corporate credit and purchasing cards, with business debit making up only a small part of card volume. Your statement's card-type breakdown shows your actual split. Debit share matters because the tool assumes a surcharge applies to credit cards only.
Use your average invoice paid by card as the average sale, and your monthly card transaction count from the statement. If you take deposits on custom orders and then collect the balance, each charge counts as a separate transaction. That can make your average sale look smaller than your average order.
Worked example: a hypothetical manufacturer
These numbers are invented for illustration only. A parts manufacturer runs $200,000 a month in card sales across 80 card transactions, an average of $2,500 per invoice. 60% of its customers pay by ACH or check, 10% of card volume is on debit, and its statement shows $5,800 in monthly fees. That makes its effective rate 2.9% from its statement. It tests a 3.5% cash discount and a 3% surcharge.
Cash discount: the program collects $7,000 a month. Fees on the larger charged amount rise to about $6,003, so the program nets about $997 more than fees. Estimated savings are $6,797 a month, or $81,564 a year. Surcharge: credit volume is $180,000, the surcharge collects $5,400, and fees rise to about $5,957. Estimated savings are $5,243 a month, or $62,921 a year. The cash discount shows about $18,643 more in estimated annual savings.
The tool would also show both rate check flags here. The 3% surcharge is above the 2.9% effective rate, and the cash discount would collect more than estimated fees. That is a signal to revisit the rates against program terms and card brand rules before going further.
On the customer side, 40% of customers would pay more under the cash discount and 36% under the surcharge. On a $2,500 invoice, a card payer would pay $87.50 more under the cash discount or $75.00 more under the surcharge. Estimates are based on published industry averages and are not a quote. Actual rates depend on card mix, ticket size, industry, and underwriting.
What changes for manufacturers' customers and operations
Your buyers usually pay against a quote or purchase order. If a card fee shows up on a charge that does not match the approved PO, accounts payable may short-pay or hold the invoice. Disclosure on quotes, invoices, order confirmations, and your online payment portal tends to matter more for you than a sign at a counter. Rules on what you must disclose, and when, vary by state and card brand, so confirm them first.
Most manufacturer card payments are card-not-present, whether taken by phone, through a virtual terminal, or from a pay-by-link invoice. Program terms and card brand rules for card-not-present transactions can differ from those at a counter. Deposits, progress billing, and recurring charges for consumables or service contracts each need the fee handled consistently on every charge.
Plan for returns and RMAs. When you refund a part or issue a credit memo, decide how the program amount is refunded. Many programs expect it to be refunded in proportion to the sale, but confirm your program's terms. Also expect pushback from distributors or key accounts with negotiated pricing. Run the customer impact numbers before you announce anything to those accounts.
What a good result looks like for manufacturers
A useful result has fee coverage close to, but not above, 100%, shows no rate check flags, and puts an extra cost on a typical invoice that your largest accounts will accept. If the gap between the two programs is small, the one that leaves debit payers and your key accounts alone may be worth more than the extra savings.
Before adding any program, review your statement for fees that no program fixes. Look for PCI non-compliance charges, monthly minimums, annual and statement fees, and non-qualified downgrades on commercial cards under tiered pricing. Commercial cards often cost more to accept than consumer cards, and sending Level 2 or Level 3 data can lower that cost on qualifying transactions if your setup supports it.
If many large invoices are paid by card only for convenience, offering ACH or eCheck on your invoices can lower your cost without changing your prices. To review your card mix, invoicing setup, and program options with someone, talk to a payments specialist.
Frequently asked questions
Most of our customers pay by ACH or check. What do I enter for share of customers who pay cash?
Enter the share of customers who pay the posted price today without a card. For most manufacturers that is ACH, check, and wire payers. Whether a specific cash discount program treats ACH and checks as cash depends on its terms, so confirm that with the program before you launch.
Nearly all our card payments are corporate or purchasing cards. Does that change the math?
It changes your effective rate, which drives every result. Commercial cards often carry higher interchange than consumer cards, so the B2B industry estimate may not match your cost. Enter your actual monthly fees so the tool calculates your rate from your statement instead of the estimate.
Our volume swings with big orders and seasonal product lines. Which month should I use?
Use a typical month, or divide your last 12 months of card sales, transactions, and fees by 12. A single unusually large order can distort your average sale and your effective rate, which shifts both savings figures.
Can we add a surcharge or cash discount to invoices that were already quoted?
The tool cannot tell you that. Disclosure rules vary by state and are also set by the card brands. As a practical matter, a fee that was not on the quote or PO often leads to disputes or short payments from accounts payable. Confirm the rules, then update your quotes and invoice templates before any program goes live.
How do we handle the program amount when a customer returns parts?
Many programs expect the surcharge or card price difference to be refunded in proportion to the amount returned. Restocking fees add another layer to work through. Confirm the refund handling in your program terms and card brand rules, and set up your RMA process to match before launch.