All free tools En espaƱol Talk to a specialist
Free tool for Indiana

Cash Discount vs Surcharge Comparison for Indiana Businesses

Whether you run a parts counter in Fort Wayne, a diner in Evansville, or a distributor shipping out of Elkhart, this tool estimates what each program could recover on your Indiana card sales and shows how prices change at your register. Select Indiana as your state and enter one typical month.

Your sales and customer mix

Used to pick an estimated industry effective rate if you do not enter your current fees.
Surcharge and cash discount rules vary by state. We use this to show what to confirm; this tool does not determine whether a program is legal in your state.
Total dollars you take on credit and debit cards in a typical month, before fees. Your processing statement shows this.
Number of card sales in a typical month.
Your typical receipt total across all customers. Used to show the price a customer would see under each program.
Rough share of all your customers who pay with cash today.
Surcharge programs generally cannot be applied to debit cards, so this changes surcharge savings. Check your statement for debit vs credit volume. If you leave it blank we use 35% as a placeholder assumption.
All fees on your last statement. If entered, we use your real effective rate instead of an industry estimate.
The non-cash adjustment added to card payments. Defaults to 3.5% as an assumption; change it to model a different rate.
The surcharge added to credit card payments. Defaults to 3% as an assumption. Card brand rules and some states may set a lower maximum; confirm before choosing a rate.

Estimates are based on published industry averages and are not a quote. Actual rates depend on card mix, ticket size, industry, and underwriting.

Your comparison

Fill in the form to compare a cash discount and a surcharge side by side.

How Indiana businesses should read this comparison

Most Indiana Main Street businesses, including hardware stores, farm supply, salons, diners, and taverns, take most cards in person. A cash discount program adds the program rate to every card sale, including debit. A credit surcharge only touches credit cards. That makes your debit share the most important input you control. Pull it from your processor statement rather than guessing, because the 35% default may not match your mix.

Your cash share matters too. Small-town shops with older regulars may see more cash than a suburban Indianapolis or Carmel storefront. More cash means fewer customers see a higher price under cash discounting. Keep in mind that the program only recovers money on card sales.

B2B sellers are different. Manufacturers, distributors, and ag suppliers that bill on invoice usually take keyed or virtual terminal payments with larger tickets. The percentage math is the same, but a 3% to 3.5% line on a five-figure invoice is something a purchasing manager will notice. Use your real average ticket so the price impact table shows what buyers would actually see.

Worked example: a hypothetical Indiana auto parts store

These numbers are entirely hypothetical. Picture a Fort Wayne auto parts store with $60,000 in monthly card sales, 1,200 card transactions, a $50 average sale, 15% cash customers, 35% debit share, and no statement uploaded. The tool therefore uses the retail industry estimate of 2.55% as its effective rate. Estimated current fees are $1,530 a month, or $18,360 a year.

Cash discount at 3.5%: the program collects about $2,100 a month. Fees after are about $1,584, so the store nets about $516 more than it pays in processing. That works out to roughly $2,046 a month, or $24,557 a year, in estimated savings. Credit surcharge at 3%: credit volume is $39,000, surcharge revenue is about $1,170, fees after are about $1,560, and estimated savings are about $1,140 a month, or $13,682 a year. Cash discounting shows about $10,875 more in annual savings on paper.

The customer side looks different. Under cash discounting, about 85% of customers pay more ($1.75 extra on a $50 sale) across all 1,200 transactions. Under surcharging, about 55% pay more ($1.50 extra) on roughly 780 transactions. In this example the tool would also show both rate check flags: the 3% surcharge is above the 2.55% estimated effective rate, and the cash discount collects more than the estimated fees. Both are signals to confirm how rates may be set before launching.

Estimates are based on published industry averages and are not a quote. Actual rates depend on card mix, ticket size, industry, and underwriting.

Indiana seasons, tips, deposits, and invoices

Indiana volume swings with the calendar. Indianapolis businesses near the track feel May, State Fair vendors and nearby restaurants feel August, and college towns like Bloomington and West Lafayette rise and fall with the academic year. Farm supply follows planting and harvest, and lakeshore towns in the northwest peak in summer. Run the tool once with a slow month and once with a peak month so you see the full range, not just one figure.

Operational details change the result. Restaurants and bars need to decide how tips interact with the card price on the receipt. RV dealers, contractors, and event venues that take deposits should decide how the program applies to a deposit and to the final balance. Gyms and service businesses with recurring billing need to update stored-payment terms. Every business needs a returns policy that covers the program amount on refunds.

What a good result looks like in Indiana, and junk fees to check first

A good result is not simply the biggest savings number. It is a program your customers will accept at a rate you can support. For a high-debit Indiana grocery or convenience store, a surcharge may recover less than you hoped. For a credit-heavy B2B or service business, the two programs may land closer together than you expect. If the gap is small, the option that changes fewer customers' prices may be worth more than the dollar difference.

Before you launch either program, read your current statement for fees that no program fixes: PCI non-compliance fees, statement and annual fees, monthly minimums, and terminal leases that run past the contract. Cutting these lowers costs without changing any price a customer sees.

Surcharge and cash discount rules vary by state and are also set by the card brands. Confirm the current rules with the card brands and your state before launching either program. The gated report includes the full monthly breakdown, a price table for your ticket sizes, and a signage checklist built around whichever program shows higher estimated savings. To review your statement line by line, talk to a payments specialist.

Frequently asked questions

Is surcharging or cash discounting allowed in Indiana?

This tool does not make that call for Indiana or any other state. Rules vary by state and are also set by the card brands, and they can change. Confirm the current rules with the card brands and your state, and consider a professional advisor, before launching either program.

I'm near the Illinois, Ohio, Michigan, or Kentucky line and also sell online. Which state should I pick?

Pick the state where you sell, which for an Indiana storefront is Indiana. If you ship to customers in other states or run locations across the border, rules there may differ. Confirm the rules for each state you sell into before applying a program to those sales.

My Indianapolis restaurant's volume jumps in May. Which month should I enter?

Run the tool twice: once with a typical month and once with your peak month. Event crowds often pay more by credit and less by cash, so update your debit and cash shares for the peak run too. Plan around the typical month and treat the peak figure as upside.

We're an Indiana manufacturer that invoices other businesses. Does this tool fit us?

Yes. Choose B2B, enter your real average invoice, and set the debit share low if few buyers pay by debit card. Then check the price impact table at your actual invoice size. It shows the dollar amount a purchasing department would see added, which helps you judge whether your buyers would accept it or move to ACH.

How should our Indiana bar handle tips under a cash discount program?

Decide whether the program rate applies before or after the tip, and make sure the receipt and your POS show it the same way every time. Card brand rules and program terms commonly address how the card price is displayed, so confirm them before you configure your terminals.

Put this calculator on your website

Accountants, bookkeepers, POS resellers, and retail or restaurant associations can embed this free cash discount vs surcharge comparison with one line of code, so owners can see both programs side by side before they talk to a processor. It stays up to date automatically.