All free tools Talk to a specialist
Free tool for eCommerce stores

Checkout Payment Method Gap Analyzer for eCommerce Stores

Online stores take almost every payment card-not-present, so small checkout gaps like a missing wallet button, a mismatched gateway, or loose fraud settings show up as abandoned carts, failed renewals, and chargebacks. Enter how your eCommerce store's checkout is set up and see which areas are red, yellow, or green.

Your checkout today

Your store
Used to pick the industry average rate assumption and to adjust fraud and ACH scoring.
The software that runs your online store.
The service that sends card transactions from your cart to the processor. Check your cart's payment settings if unsure.
Payment methods your checkout offers
Check every payment method your checkout offers today.
Orders and checkout
Average completed online sales per month, before refunds.
Large orders are where bank payments (ACH) matter most.
From your cart or analytics reports: share of started checkouts that did not complete. Leave blank if you don't know.
Subscriptions
Fraud screening
Whether your gateway checks the billing address and the 3- or 4-digit card code.
Optional what-if
Your own assumption, not a benchmark. Leave blank to skip the what-if.

Estimates are based on published industry averages and are not a quote. Actual rates depend on card mix, ticket size, industry, and underwriting.

Your checkout gap report

Answer the questions to see a green, yellow, or red score for each checkout area.

Why checkout gaps cost eCommerce stores more than in-store sellers

A retail counter can fall back on a tap or a chip read. An eCommerce store gets one shot, usually on a phone, often from a shopper who arrived from an ad and has no saved account with you. If the payment method they want is missing, or the card form asks them to retype a 16-digit number on a small screen, they can leave without you ever seeing why.

Nearly all of your volume is card-not-present, which shapes everything this tool checks. Wallets matter because they skip manual card entry on mobile. Fraud screening matters because the shopper never hands you a physical card. Gateway fit matters because your cart, gateway, and processor all have to talk to each other cleanly for refunds, recurring charges, and fraud tools to work.

Seasonality raises the stakes. Many online stores do a large share of their year around holiday promotions and sale events, and that is exactly when a missing wallet or an overly strict fraud rule hurts most. Run the analyzer before your peak season, not during it.

What a good result looks like for an eCommerce store

For a typical online store selling physical goods with order values under a few hundred dollars, a strong result is green on wallets (both Apple Pay and Google Pay on), green on gateway and cart fit, and green or yellow on fraud screening. ACH will often show green with a 'low priority' note, which is a fine outcome: if your orders rarely pass $1,000, bank payments are not where your gaps are.

Stores with larger tickets, such as furniture, equipment, or wholesale orders through a storefront, should expect ACH to matter more. When ACH shows yellow or red, the tool shows an estimated card processing cost on a $1,000 order using an assumed eCommerce average rate of 3.15%, or $31.50. That figure is an assumption from published industry averages, not your rate and not a TouchSuite quote.

Subscription box and replenishment stores get a fourth area scored: whether stored cards update automatically when customers get new cards, and how failed renewals are retried. Green here means both are handled; red usually means renewals are failing quietly every month.

Estimates are based on published industry averages and are not a quote. Actual rates depend on card mix, ticket size, industry, and underwriting.

Worked example: a hypothetical eCommerce store

These numbers are made up to show how the tool works. Picture a Shopify store doing $40,000 a month in online revenue, with a cart abandonment rate it believes is 70%. It offers cards and Apple Pay but not Google Pay, uses Shopify's built-in payments, has AVS and CVV on, and is not sure whether any other fraud filters are running. It also sells a monthly subscription box with 400 active subscribers, 24 failed renewals a month, and a $35 average renewal charge.

Results: wallets yellow (Google Pay missing), gateway and cart fit green, fraud yellow (one point for 'not sure' on filters), ACH green with the low-priority note. On subscriptions, the store answers 'not sure' for card updater and 'platform default' for retries, scoring yellow. The failed renewal rate shows as 6%, and renewal revenue at risk is $840 a month, or $10,080 a year.

The owner enters a 3% recovery assumption. Abandoned revenue works out to $40,000 x 0.70 / 0.30, about $93,333 a month, so recovering 3% of it is about $2,800 a month or $33,600 a year. On the subscription side, 3% of $840 is $25.20 a month, or $302.40 a year. The 3% is the owner's assumption, not a benchmark.

Estimates are based on published industry averages and are not a quote. Actual rates depend on card mix, ticket size, industry, and underwriting.

What eCommerce stores should watch for after running the check

Gateway fees layered on processing fees. Online stores often pay a gateway fee, a per-transaction fee, and a processor markup, plus possible PCI compliance or non-compliance fees and chargeback fees. If you marked your gateway 'not sure,' that area turns red because you cannot compare any of these without knowing what is actually processing your cards.

Third-party gateways on hosted carts. If you are on Shopify and use Authorize.net or NMI, confirm the gateway is supported as a Shopify payment provider and check whether your Shopify plan adds a fee for using a third-party gateway. On WooCommerce, Magento, or BigCommerce, confirm the plugin or extension is actively maintained.

Fraud rules that block good customers. Drop shipping, high-demand product launches, and international traffic can all trigger velocity or country rules. Tight filters lower chargebacks but can decline real buyers. If your fraud area is yellow or red, the Chargeback Risk Scorecard helps you weigh the tradeoff. If you sell subscriptions, the Failed Payment Revenue Loss Calculator goes deeper on renewals.

Refunds and returns. Returns are routine for online apparel, beauty, and similar categories. Make sure your gateway handles partial refunds cleanly from inside your cart, so staff are not issuing refunds in a separate dashboard and losing track of them.

Frequently asked questions

My online store's average order is around $50. Do I need to bother with ACH?

Probably not first. The tool marks ACH as low priority when your orders rarely exceed $1,000 and you are not a B2B seller. For small-ticket stores, wallet coverage and fraud settings usually matter more. If you also take large wholesale or bulk orders, answer 'sometimes' or 'often' and the tool will flag ACH accordingly.

I use my cart's built-in payments. What should I select as my gateway?

Choose the built-in or platform default option. On Shopify, WooCommerce, Magento, or BigCommerce that is scored as green for gateway fit. If you run a custom or other cart, the tool marks it yellow, because 'built-in' is unclear there and you should confirm which company actually processes your cards.

I run a subscription box. What does 'stored cards update automatically' mean?

When a subscriber's card is reissued with a new number or expiration date, an account updater service can refresh the stored card so the next renewal does not fail. If you are not sure whether yours is on, the tool counts that as a partial gap. Ask your gateway or subscription app whether card updating is enabled and whether it costs extra.

Should my eCommerce store add buy now, pay later?

The tool shows BNPL for information only and does not score it. BNPL providers charge merchants fees, so whether it pays off depends on your order sizes and margins. It tends to be worth a look for higher-priced items and less so for low-margin, low-ticket products.

Can I add a surcharge to card payments at checkout to cover processing costs?

This tool does not answer that, and rules on surcharging and cash discounting vary. Confirm with the card brands and your state before adding any surcharge or checkout fee. A payments specialist can walk through pricing options with you.

Put this calculator on your website

Shopify and WooCommerce developers, eCommerce agencies, and consultants can embed this free checkout gap analyzer on a client resource page with one line of code. Store owners get the same five-area scorecard, and it stays up to date automatically.