All free tools Talk to a specialist
Free tool for property management companies

Checkout Payment Method Gap Analyzer for Property Management Companies

Property management companies collect large, recurring, almost entirely online payments, so gaps in ACH, autopay card handling, and fraud screening cost more than they would at a typical online store. Run your resident portal through the analyzer to see which of those gaps apply to you.

Your checkout today

Your store
Used to pick the industry average rate assumption and to adjust fraud and ACH scoring.
The software that runs your online store.
The service that sends card transactions from your cart to the processor. Check your cart's payment settings if unsure.
Payment methods your checkout offers
Check every payment method your checkout offers today.
Orders and checkout
Average completed online sales per month, before refunds.
Large orders are where bank payments (ACH) matter most.
From your cart or analytics reports: share of started checkouts that did not complete. Leave blank if you don't know.
Subscriptions
Fraud screening
Whether your gateway checks the billing address and the 3- or 4-digit card code.
Optional what-if
Your own assumption, not a benchmark. Leave blank to skip the what-if.

Estimates are based on published industry averages and are not a quote. Actual rates depend on card mix, ticket size, industry, and underwriting.

Your checkout gap report

Answer the questions to see a green, yellow, or red score for each checkout area.

How property management companies should answer the inputs

Choose Professional services as your business type. Most property management companies collect rent through a resident portal built into their property management software, not a store builder, so pick Custom or Other as your cart platform unless you take payments on a site-builder storefront.

For Current payment gateway, choose the processor that actually runs your card and bank payments. If your software vendor handles payments and you are not sure who processes them, pick Not sure. That produces an honest red result, and it is the most useful thing to learn: you cannot compare fees, fraud tools, or autopay support without knowing your gateway.

For Monthly online revenue, include rent, fees, deposits, and dues collected online. Leave out checks and money orders. If typical rents are above $1,000, answer Often to the large-orders question.

Answer Yes to subscriptions if residents can enroll in autopay. Enter autopay enrollments as Active subscribers, failed autopay charges as Failed renewals per month, and average autopay rent as Average renewal charge.

What is different about payments for property management companies

Rent is a high-ticket payment, nearly all of it card-not-present, and it arrives in a surge in the first few days of each month. Move-in season adds security deposits and first-month payments. Application fees arrive year-round from people you have never met. There is no tipping and there are no product returns, but deposit refunds, move-out disputes, and returned bank payments create their own reconciliation work.

Because tickets are large, ACH usually matters more than wallets. If ACH is yellow or red, the tool shows an estimated card cost on a $1,000 payment at the assumed professional services average of 2.9%, which is $29. The tool shows no ACH cost and makes no ACH comparison. Estimates are based on published industry averages and are not a quote. Actual rates depend on card mix, ticket size, industry, and underwriting.

Many property managers add a convenience fee or surcharge for residents who pay by card. Rules vary by card brand and by state, and your leases or local housing rules may also apply. Confirm with the card brands and your state before you charge or change any fee.

Apple Pay and Google Pay matter less for rent than for application fees and one-time charges that prospects pay on a phone. Buy now, pay later appears as information only. BNPL providers charge merchant fees, so whether it is worth offering depends on the size and margin of the payment, and it is rarely a fit for rent.

Worked example: a hypothetical property management company

Every number here is hypothetical. A company collects $450,000 a month online, accepts cards through its software's built-in payments on a Custom/Other portal, and does not offer ACH, Apple Pay, or Google Pay. Rents are usually above $1,000. It has 200 residents on autopay, 8 failed autopay charges a month, and an average autopay rent of $1,450. It is not sure whether stored cards update automatically, it uses the platform's default retry, it runs both AVS and CVV, and it is not sure about other fraud filters.

Results: Wallets red (no wallets). ACH red, with the estimated $29 card cost per $1,000. Subscription billing yellow (2 points). Gateway and cart fit yellow, because built-in payments on a custom or other portal leaves unclear who processes the cards. Fraud screening yellow (1 point). Headline: 2 red and 3 yellow gaps found.

Autopay numbers: failed renewal rate is 8 / 200 = 4%, shown without a benchmark. Renewal revenue at risk is 8 x $1,450 = $11,600 a month, or $139,200 a year. If the owner enters a 5% recovery assumption, the subscription what-if shows $580 a month and $6,960 a year. Estimates are based on published industry averages and are not a quote. Actual rates depend on card mix, ticket size, industry, and underwriting.

The gated fix plan lists the reds first, wallets then ACH, followed by the yellows: gateway and cart fit, subscription billing, then fraud screening. Each item comes with a setup note for this portal and gateway combination.

What a good result looks like for property management companies

Aim for green on ACH, gateway and cart fit, and fraud screening. Those three carry the most weight when payments are large and fully online. Green on gateway fit means you can name your processor and confirm it supports recurring billing for your portal.

Autopay should move from yellow to green once stored cards update automatically and failed charges are retried on a smart schedule, not just a platform default. Wallets at yellow can be a reasonable result if prospects rarely pay application fees on a phone.

If fraud screening comes back yellow or red, the results link to the Chargeback Risk Scorecard. If you offer autopay, they link to the Failed Payment Revenue Loss Calculator. The printable checklist fills in your status for each area so you can hand it to your software vendor or accounting team.

Frequently asked questions

Our property management software handles payments. Why does gateway fit show yellow or red?

With a Custom/Other portal and built-in payments, the tool cannot tell who actually processes your cards, so it flags yellow. If you chose Not sure, it shows red. Ask your software vendor which processor and gateway sit behind the portal. Once you know, you can compare fees, fraud tools, and autopay support.

Should resident autopay count as subscriptions in this tool?

Yes. Autopay is recurring billing, so the same risks apply: cards expire, get replaced, or decline. Answer Yes, enter autopay enrollments as active subscribers, and enter your average autopay rent as the renewal charge. That lets the tool estimate the rent at risk from failed charges.

Can we charge residents a convenience fee for paying rent by card?

The analyzer does not judge fee practices. Rules for surcharges and convenience fees vary by card brand and by state, and your leases or local housing rules may also apply. Confirm with the card brands and your state, and review your lease language, before you add or change a fee.

Rent is owed either way. How should we read the checkout what-if?

A rent payment a resident abandons usually turns into a late payment, not a lost sale, so read the checkout what-if as an estimate of collection timing more than new revenue. Application fees from prospects who give up are closer to true lost revenue. Keep your recovery assumption conservative and treat every figure as your own assumption.

Residents sometimes dispute a card payment after move-out. Which part of the tool covers that?

Fraud screening is the closest fit. AVS, CVV, and filters such as payment amount limits help with stolen-card payments on applications and move-in funds. They do not stop a disagreement with a former resident. If fraud screening shows yellow or red, use the linked Chargeback Risk Scorecard for a fuller look at your dispute exposure.

Put this calculator on your website

Shopify and WooCommerce developers, eCommerce agencies, and consultants can embed this free checkout gap analyzer on a client resource page with one line of code. Store owners get the same five-area scorecard, and it stays up to date automatically.