All free tools En español Talk to a specialist
Free tool for moving companies

Card vs ACH vs Check: What Each Payment Method Really Costs Your Moving Company

Moving companies get paid in several ways at once: card deposits at booking, balances collected on delivery day, commercial relocation invoices paid by check weeks later, and monthly storage bills. Enter your own mix below to see what each method costs you in fees, office time, and cash stuck in transit, and what changes if some of your check volume moves to ACH or card.

Your invoices and payment mix

Sets the default card effective rate if you leave that field blank. Most users of this tool are B2B (wholesale, distribution, manufacturing).
Total dollars collected on invoices in a typical month, across all payment methods.
Typical invoice size. Used to estimate how many payments you process each month.

How customers pay you

Percent of invoice dollars paid by credit or debit card. The three shares must add up to 100%.
Percent of invoice dollars paid by ACH, eCheck, or bank transfer.
Percent of invoice dollars paid by mailed or hand-delivered paper check. The 20 / 30 / 50 starting mix is a placeholder; replace it with yours.
Shares total: 100%

Days from invoice to cash

Days from sending the invoice to funds landing in your bank account. Default is a placeholder assumption; replace it with your own number.
Days from sending the invoice to ACH funds settling. Default is a placeholder assumption.
Days from sending the invoice to the check clearing, including mail time and deposit. Default is a placeholder assumption.

Your card rate

Total card fees for a month divided by total card volume. Leave blank to use the industry average assumption for your business type (2.80% for B2B).

Fees and staff time (assumptions, edit any value)

These start as placeholder assumptions, not facts about your business. Replace them with numbers from your bank statement and your own timing.

What your bank or processor charges per incoming ACH. $0.50 is a placeholder assumption; check your statement.
Bank deposit fees, remote deposit or lockbox fees, and courier or bank trip costs per check. $0.50 is a placeholder assumption.
Loaded hourly cost of the person who handles payments. $25 is a placeholder assumption.
Time to open, match to invoice, post, deposit, and reconcile one check. 10 minutes is a placeholder assumption.
Time to match and post one ACH payment. 3 minutes is a placeholder assumption.
Time to run or match and post one card payment. 3 minutes is a placeholder assumption.

Cost of cash

What money waiting in receivables costs you per year, such as your line of credit rate. 10% is a placeholder assumption.
Who processes your card payments today, if anyone. Helps tailor the report notes.

Estimates are based on published industry averages and are not a quote. Actual rates depend on card mix, ticket size, industry, and underwriting.

What getting paid costs you

Enter your monthly invoiced revenue and average invoice amount to see the comparison.

How Moving Companies Actually Get Paid

Most moving companies run at least two payment patterns side by side. Residential moves often start with a deposit taken over the phone or online, which is a card-not-present transaction, then the balance is collected when the truck is unloaded, by card on a mobile reader, a keyed card, or a certified check. Commercial and office relocations, corporate relocation accounts, and third-party billing usually work on invoices with payment terms, and those tend to arrive by paper check or ACH.

Storage adds a third pattern: smaller recurring monthly charges that suit card-on-file or ACH autopay. Crew tips are a fourth wrinkle. If customers add tips on a card, those tips run through your merchant account and carry the same processing cost as the move itself, even though the money goes to the crew.

For this tool, enter the shares for invoiced revenue only, meaning the deposits, balances, and invoices you bill. If tips are processed on your account and you want to see their real cost, include them in monthly volume. Leave out cash payments, since the tool compares card, ACH, and check.

Filling In the Inputs for a Moving Company

Card rate: the default card rate depends on the business type you pick. Moving is often underwritten as a higher-risk category because the service is delivered after the deposit is taken, so the high-risk default is an assumed 4.25%, while the B2B default is an assumed 2.8%. Both are placeholder estimates. Your own number is better: divide total processing fees by total card volume from a recent statement and enter that. Keyed deposits taken by phone usually price higher than cards dipped or tapped at delivery, so a mover heavy on phone deposits may see a higher effective rate than one that collects most balances in person.

Days to cash: for card, count from the delivery date to the day funds land in your bank. If your processor holds a rolling reserve, note that this tool does not model reserves, so your real card timing may be slower than the number you enter. For checks, count from invoice to cleared funds, including the time a driver holds a check before it gets back to the office.

Staff minutes: be honest about check handling. It typically includes the driver turning in the check, office logging, matching it to the bill of lading or invoice, the deposit itself, and follow-up calls on late commercial payers. ACH and card usually need less handling, but count any time spent matching remittance details.

Seasonality: moving volume usually swings hard between the peak season and the slow months. Run the tool twice, once with a busy month and once with a quiet month. The cost of slow checks matters most when payroll and fuel are highest.

Worked Example: A Hypothetical Regional Moving Company

These numbers are made up for illustration. A regional mover invoices $120,000 a month with a $2,400 average invoice, so about 50 invoices. The mix is 40% card, 20% ACH, and 40% check. Days to cash are assumed at 2 for card, 5 for ACH, and 35 for check. The owner enters a 3.9% card rate from the statement, $0.50 per ACH payment, $3 out-of-pocket per check, $30 per hour for office staff, 3 staff minutes per card payment, 4 per ACH payment, 12 per check, and a 10% annual cost of cash.

Baseline result: about $2,107 a month in fees and staff time plus about $527 in carrying cost on cash in transit, for a total near $2,634 a month. About $63,200 is tied up in collection at any time, and almost all of it, $56,000, sits in checks. Weighted days to cash is 15.8.

Scenario 1, all checks moved to ACH: total cost drops to about $2,104 a month, saving roughly $530, and about $48,000 of cash is freed, with weighted days to cash falling to 3.8. Scenario 2, all checks moved to card: about $52,800 is freed and weighted days falls to 2.6, but total cost rises to about $3,916 a month, an additional cost of roughly $1,282, because card fees on large invoices outweigh the carrying cost saved. In this example, ACH is the better trade for check-paying commercial accounts.

Estimates are based on published industry averages and are not a quote. Actual rates depend on card mix, ticket size, industry, and underwriting.

What a Good Result Looks Like for Moving Companies, and What to Watch

For most movers, a good result is not "get everyone on card." It is getting commercial and corporate accounts off paper checks and onto ACH, keeping card for deposits and delivery-day balances where speed and convenience matter, and moving storage to autopay. If your weighted days to cash drops meaningfully without total cost rising, that is a solid mix. The full report runs four mix scenarios against your baseline and shows which one is cheapest for your numbers.

Large-ticket moves: with average invoices of $1,000 or more, the report adds questions to ask about large-ticket card pricing, including whether passing Level 2 or Level 3 data on commercial and corporate cards could apply to your relocation accounts. Large card tickets also raise dispute exposure, since a damage claim or a final bill above the estimate can turn into a chargeback. This tool does not model chargebacks, so weigh that separately.

Statement line items: look for PCI non-compliance fees, monthly minimums, statement and annual fees, batch or gateway fees, and early termination terms. These are not in the card rate field unless you included them in your effective rate calculation. If checks from commercial accounts regularly take 45 days or more, the report links to our Merchant Funding Payback Estimator so you can compare the cost of waiting with the cost of funding. To review your results with someone who knows moving company payments, talk to a payments specialist.

Frequently asked questions

Should my moving company choose "High-risk" or "B2B" as the business type?

Business type only changes the default card rate when you leave the card rate field blank. If most of your revenue is residential moves with card deposits, the high-risk default is closer to how movers are often priced; if you mainly do commercial relocations on invoice, B2B may fit better. Both defaults are estimates. The most accurate option is to enter your own effective rate: total processing fees divided by total card volume from a recent statement.

How do I handle deposits taken at booking and balances collected on delivery day?

Treat them as separate payments. Each one is a transaction, so count both in your monthly volume and let your average invoice reflect the real average payment size. Deposits taken by phone are usually keyed, card-not-present transactions, and balances taken on a reader at delivery are usually card-present, which is one reason your blended card rate may differ from the default.

Can I pass card fees on to customers with a surcharge or cash discount?

Rules for surcharging and cash discount programs vary, and they differ by card brand and by state. Confirm with the card brands and your state before changing how you price a move. This tool does not model surcharging; it shows what each payment method costs you today and under different mixes.

Our commercial clients pay by check on net-30 or net-45 terms. Is it worth pushing them to ACH?

Run the scenario slider with your real check days and staff minutes and see. In many mixes, ACH removes most of the carrying cost and office time of checks for a small per-payment fee. If checks take 45 days or longer, or your weighted days to cash is 30 or more, the report also points you to the Merchant Funding Payback Estimator so you can see what bridging that gap would cost.

Do crew tips on cards belong in this calculation?

If customers add tips to a card payment processed on your merchant account, you pay processing on those tips even though the money goes to the crew. Include them in monthly volume if you want the true cost of card acceptance. If tips are paid in cash or directly to crew outside your account, leave them out.

Put this calculator on your website

Accountants, fractional CFOs, bookkeepers, and distribution and manufacturing associations can embed this free card vs ACH vs check comparison with one line of code, so clients can see what their invoice payment mix costs. It stays up to date automatically.