All free tools En español Talk to a specialist
Free tool for nutraceutical and supplement sellers

Card vs ACH vs Check: Invoice Payment Costs for Nutraceutical and Supplement Sellers

If you sell supplements wholesale to health food stores, gyms, practitioners, or distributors, your invoices probably arrive as a mix of mailed checks, bank transfers, and keyed-in cards, and each one costs you differently. Enter your own numbers below to see what that mix costs nutraceutical and supplement sellers like you in fees, staff time, and cash stuck in collection.

Your invoices and payment mix

Sets the default card effective rate if you leave that field blank. Most users of this tool are B2B (wholesale, distribution, manufacturing).
Total dollars collected on invoices in a typical month, across all payment methods.
Typical invoice size. Used to estimate how many payments you process each month.

How customers pay you

Percent of invoice dollars paid by credit or debit card. The three shares must add up to 100%.
Percent of invoice dollars paid by ACH, eCheck, or bank transfer.
Percent of invoice dollars paid by mailed or hand-delivered paper check. The 20 / 30 / 50 starting mix is a placeholder; replace it with yours.
Shares total: 100%

Days from invoice to cash

Days from sending the invoice to funds landing in your bank account. Default is a placeholder assumption; replace it with your own number.
Days from sending the invoice to ACH funds settling. Default is a placeholder assumption.
Days from sending the invoice to the check clearing, including mail time and deposit. Default is a placeholder assumption.

Your card rate

Total card fees for a month divided by total card volume. Leave blank to use the industry average assumption for your business type (2.80% for B2B).

Fees and staff time (assumptions, edit any value)

These start as placeholder assumptions, not facts about your business. Replace them with numbers from your bank statement and your own timing.

What your bank or processor charges per incoming ACH. $0.50 is a placeholder assumption; check your statement.
Bank deposit fees, remote deposit or lockbox fees, and courier or bank trip costs per check. $0.50 is a placeholder assumption.
Loaded hourly cost of the person who handles payments. $25 is a placeholder assumption.
Time to open, match to invoice, post, deposit, and reconcile one check. 10 minutes is a placeholder assumption.
Time to match and post one ACH payment. 3 minutes is a placeholder assumption.
Time to run or match and post one card payment. 3 minutes is a placeholder assumption.

Cost of cash

What money waiting in receivables costs you per year, such as your line of credit rate. 10% is a placeholder assumption.
Who processes your card payments today, if anyone. Helps tailor the report notes.

Estimates are based on published industry averages and are not a quote. Actual rates depend on card mix, ticket size, industry, and underwriting.

What getting paid costs you

Enter your monthly invoiced revenue and average invoice amount to see the comparison.

How nutraceutical and supplement sellers actually get paid on invoices

Supplement brands that sell B2B often have three kinds of customers paying in three different ways. Independent health food stores and smaller practitioner offices, such as chiropractors and naturopaths, often mail a check. Larger distributors and regional chains tend to pay by ACH on net terms. New accounts, gyms, and small reorders often pay by card through an emailed payment link or a virtual terminal.

That last point matters. Almost every card payment on a wholesale invoice is card-not-present: the customer types a number into a link, or your staff keys it in. Keyed and online transactions are generally priced higher than tapped or dipped ones, so your effective card rate on invoices may be higher than what a retail store pays.

Contract manufacturing and private-label work add another layer. If you take deposits up front to buy raw materials, or collect a balance before a production run ships, those payments tend to be large and time-sensitive. Seasonal reorder waves, such as stores stocking up ahead of New Year and spring fitness pushes, can bunch a lot of invoices into a few weeks, which is when slow check payments hurt your cash the most.

Choosing the right card rate as a nutraceutical or supplement seller

The tool fills in a placeholder card rate if you leave that field blank, and the one it uses depends on the business type you pick. Choose High-risk and it assumes 4.25%; choose B2B and it assumes 2.8%. Both are assumptions based on published industry averages, not your actual pricing. Nutraceuticals are commonly underwritten as a higher-risk category, so the B2B default may understate your costs.

The better move is to enter your own effective rate. Take one month's statement, add up every processing-related charge, and divide by your total card volume. Include the line items that are easy to overlook in this category: high-risk program or account fees, PCI non-compliance fees, monthly minimums, statement and gateway fees, and per-transaction authorization fees.

If your processor holds a rolling reserve, that is not a fee, but it does tie up cash. The tool does not model reserves directly. One rough workaround is to increase your card days-to-cash input to reflect how long part of your card money actually sits before you can use it, and note that this is an approximation.

Worked example: a hypothetical supplement wholesaler

These numbers are entirely hypothetical and chosen to show how the math works. A supplement brand invoices $120,000 a month at an average of $1,500 per invoice, or 80 invoices. 30% is paid by card, 30% by ACH, and 40% by check. Cash arrives in 3 days by card, 5 by ACH, and 40 by check. The owner enters a card rate of 4.0% from their statement, $0.50 per ACH payment, $5 out-of-pocket per check, $35 per hour for staff, 3 / 4 / 12 staff minutes per card / ACH / check payment, and a 10% annual cost of cash.

Baseline result: about $1,934 a month in fees and staff time, plus about $613 in carrying cost on $73,600 of cash tied up in collection, for roughly $2,547 a month in total, around 2.1% of volume. Weighted days to cash: 18.4. Checks are only 40% of volume but about $533 of the carrying cost, because 40 days is a long wait.

Moving half of the check share to ACH (checks 20%, ACH 50%) drops the total to about $2,167 a month, a saving of about $380, frees about $28,000 of cash, and cuts weighted days to 11.4. Moving all checks to card instead frees about $59,200 of cash and gets weighted days down to 3.6, but at a 4.0% card rate it adds about $1,099 a month in cost. That trade-off between speed and fees is the main decision most supplement wholesalers face.

Estimates are based on published industry averages and are not a quote. Actual rates depend on card mix, ticket size, industry, and underwriting.

What a good result looks like for nutraceutical and supplement sellers

For most supplement brands, a good result is not "get everyone on card." It is getting check-paying reorder accounts onto ACH or eCheck, keeping card available for new accounts, small orders, and customers who want to use a business card, and bringing weighted days to cash down without letting card fees eat into wholesale margins that are often thinner than your direct-to-consumer margins.

Because supplement wholesale invoices often run large, the full report adds a section on large-ticket card pricing when your average invoice is $1,000 or more, including questions to ask about Level 2 and Level 3 data on commercial and purchasing cards. If checks are 30% or more of your mix, it emphasizes ACH, eCheck, and virtual terminal setup so practitioners and stores can pay you electronically without changing their own bank.

If your weighted days to cash reach 30 or more, or checks take 45 days or longer, the report links to our Merchant Funding Payback Estimator so you can weigh the cost of waiting against the cost of bridging a slow season. Unlock the full report to see all four recommended mix scenarios side by side, or talk to a payments specialist about your own statement.

Frequently asked questions

Will card payments on my supplement wholesale invoices be priced as high risk even though the buyers are businesses?

It depends on how a processor underwrites your account, and many underwrite nutraceuticals as a higher-risk category regardless of whether you sell B2B or direct to consumer. We can't predict your classification or rate. That's why the tool works best with the effective rate from your own statement rather than either default placeholder.

Can I add a surcharge or fee when a health food store pays my invoice by card?

Rules on surcharging and card fees vary by card brand and by state, and they change. Confirm the current card brand rules and your state's requirements before adding any fee to invoices. The tool shows what card acceptance costs you today so you can decide how to handle it with accurate numbers.

Retailers send back short-dated or expired product. How do returns and credit memos affect this comparison?

The tool doesn't model returns. If you refund a card payment, check your processing agreement to see whether the original fee is returned; on many plans it isn't, which raises your real card cost. Issuing a credit memo against the next invoice avoids moving money twice, whatever payment method the account uses.

Our chiropractor and gym accounts reorder the same products every month. Is ACH worth setting up for them?

For predictable recurring orders, ACH with a signed debit authorization usually removes the mailing and depositing steps that make checks slow and staff-heavy. Run the scenario slider moving part of your check share to ACH to see what it's worth in staff time and cash freed for your volume.

Do Level 2 and Level 3 data matter for distributors that pay my invoices with a purchasing card?

They can. Some commercial and purchasing card transactions may qualify for different interchange categories when additional invoice data, such as tax amount, PO number, and line items, is passed with the payment. Whether you benefit depends on your card mix, gateway, and pricing structure, so ask your processor how they handle it.

Put this calculator on your website

Accountants, fractional CFOs, bookkeepers, and distribution and manufacturing associations can embed this free card vs ACH vs check comparison with one line of code, so clients can see what their invoice payment mix costs. It stays up to date automatically.