Processor Switch Break-Even Planner for Manufacturers
Manufacturers usually take large, keyed-in or invoiced card payments, often on corporate and purchasing cards, so small rate differences add up fast. Enter your contract, lease, and statement numbers to see how many months it would take a switch to pay for itself.
Your break-even
One more number needed. Enter your expected monthly savings, or your average ticket size so we can estimate savings, to see your months to break even and net gain or loss.
0%
Your first 5 steps
- Find the termination clause in your merchant agreement (search 'termination', 'cancellation', 'liquidated damages', 'auto-renew') and note any notice period.
- Check your equipment lease end date and whether it is a separate, non-cancelable contract.
- Download your last 3 months of processing statements.
- List every integration that touches payments: POS, gateway, shopping cart, invoicing, recurring billing.
- Set a target cutover date and work backward from it.
If your lease is owed either way
Switch now or wait out your contract
24 months at a glance
- - - Cumulative cost if you stay —— Cumulative cost if you switch
A specialist can review your statement and agreement with you. This planner is not a quote.
How manufacturers should fill in the planner
Monthly card volume: manufacturing revenue is often lumpy. One large distributor order or a seasonal production run can double a month. Average your last three to six statements instead of using your best or worst month, because the planner assumes your savings stay the same every month.
Current total monthly processing cost: add every line on the statement, not just the rate. Include PCI non-compliance fees, monthly minimums, statement and batch fees, annual or regulatory fees, gateway fees, and any 'non-qualified' or 'mid-qualified' surcharges. On tiered pricing, commercial and purchasing cards often land in those higher tiers, which is where many manufacturers find the gap.
Payment channels: most manufacturer card volume is card-not-present. That means phone orders keyed into a virtual terminal, payment links on invoices, or a B2B storefront. Check Virtual terminal and Online gateway if that is you. Check Countertop terminal only if you run a will-call counter, a factory store, or a trade-show booth.
Expected monthly savings: if you have a quote or a statement review, enter that figure. If you leave it blank and enter an average ticket, the planner estimates savings using an assumed B2B interchange average. A mix heavy in corporate, purchasing, or rewards cards can run above that assumption, so treat the estimate as a starting point.
Worked example: a hypothetical parts manufacturer
All numbers here are hypothetical. A small manufacturer processes $120,000 a month in card payments, mostly keyed phone orders and invoice payments, and pays $3,600 a month in total processing costs. That is a 3.00% effective rate, shown next to the planner's B2B assumption of 2.80%. The contract has 10 months left and a $495 early termination fee. A countertop terminal at the will-call desk is leased at $49 a month with 18 months remaining. Re-connecting invoice payment links and staff time are estimated at $300.
Exit cost is $495 + (18 x $49) = $1,377. Total upfront cost is $1,377 + $300 = $1,677. After a statement review, the owner enters $600 a month in expected savings. Break-even is 1,677 / 600 = 2.8, rounded up to 3 months, which the tool rates 'Strong case to switch.' The 12-month net is a $5,523 gain and the 24-month net is a $12,723 gain.
If the lease is a separate contract that has to be paid either way, the switching cost drops to $795 and break-even falls to 2 months. Because the contract has 10 months left, waiting would give up 10 x $600 = $6,000 in savings to avoid a $495 fee. In this example, switching now comes out ahead by $5,505.
Estimates are based on published industry averages and are not a quote. Actual rates depend on card mix, ticket size, industry, and underwriting.
Switching costs manufacturers tend to miss
Stored cards for repeat buyers. If distributors or dealers reorder on a card you keep on file, those cards are stored as tokens with your current gateway. Ask your current provider in writing whether they will release the card data to a new processor, and plan for customers you may need to contact again. Count any staff time as part of the one-time switch cost.
Invoicing and system connections. Payment links in your invoicing or accounting software, a B2B cart such as Magento or BigCommerce, and any ERP connection to your gateway may all need to be reconfigured. Get an hour estimate from whoever maintains them before you trust the break-even number.
Deposits, refunds, and RMAs. Many manufacturers take deposits on custom or made-to-order work and process returns weeks later. Ask your current processor how refunds and chargebacks on transactions processed with them will be handled after you leave, and do not close the old account until open orders and return windows have cleared.
What a good result looks like for manufacturers
With large tickets, even a modest rate improvement can cover a termination fee within a few months. If the planner shows break-even in the 13 to 24 month range, ask about a lease buyout or a lower termination fee before you decide. If it shows no payback, validate your statement first. The problem may be fee lines or card-mix downgrades you can fix by asking the right questions, rather than the processor itself.
Time the cutover for a slower production or ordering period, not the week before a big shipment cycle. Check your contract's auto-renewal notice window, since missing it can reset the term and the termination fee.
Questions to bring to any provider: Can you pass Level 2 and Level 3 data on commercial card transactions? Do you offer ACH for large invoices? How are keyed transactions priced compared with card-present ones? The gated results include a cancellation letter and a migration checklist based on your hardware, gateway, cart, and recurring billing setup. When you have them, talk to a payments specialist to review your actual statement.
Frequently asked questions
Most of our customers pay with corporate or purchasing cards. Will the planner's estimate reflect that?
Only roughly. If you leave savings blank, the planner uses an assumed average interchange for B2B businesses, and commercial card interchange can run higher than that, especially when transactions go through without Level 2 or Level 3 data. For a more accurate result, get savings from a statement review and enter that figure as expected monthly savings.
Our volume swings a lot between big orders. Which month's numbers should we use?
Use an average of three to six months of statements for both volume and total cost. The planner assumes savings are the same every month and does not model growth or seasonality, so one unusually large order can make switching look better or worse than it is.
We keep cards on file for distributors who reorder. Do we lose those when we switch?
Not necessarily, but it depends on whether your current provider will transfer the stored card tokens. Check 'I charge saved cards or run recurring billing' and the gated checklist adds a card-token migration section with the questions to ask and steps to plan for any customers you need to contact again.
Should we move large invoices to ACH instead of switching card processors?
They can work together. ACH is often a lower-cost option for large B2B invoices, but some buyers prefer to pay by card for payment terms or rewards. Run the planner on your card volume alone, then ask a specialist how ACH and eCheck could fit alongside it. Rules on passing card fees to customers vary by card brand and state, so confirm with the card brands and your state before adding any surcharge.
We lease one terminal for our will-call counter. Does that lease really count as a switching cost?
The main result counts every remaining lease payment as a cost of switching, which is the conservative view. Many equipment leases are separate, non-cancelable contracts that continue whether or not you change processors. In that case the gated 'lease owed either way' view gives you a more realistic break-even. Read your lease agreement to see which case applies to you.